Providence,
November 16, 2026
Few Americans went to the polls driven by foreign policy issues. Instead, voters say they were motivated by the rising price of fuel and groceries, the cost of living, corruption, presidential overreach and presidential performance. But whether or not voters recognize it, foreign policy issues—Ukraine and Russia, Iran and the Strait of Hormuz, tariffs and immigration and foreign influence—played a major role in the midterms, because foreign policy issues directly impacted those domestic issues.
Will the election outcome impact how President Donald Trump and a demoralized, diminished Republican Party conduct foreign policy? And what role can a revitalized, supersized Democratic Party play in shaping foreign policy from the other side of Pennsylvania Avenue?
Good Advice
Course corrections on foreign policy could help Trump’s party address the issues that triggered the midterm rout. The party could start that process by heeding the advice of some of the party’s foremost statesmen.
“In giving freedom to the slave, we assure freedom to the free,” President Abraham Lincoln explained. “We shall nobly save, or meanly lose, the last best hope of earth,” he warned, adding that the way forward “is plain, peaceful, generous, just—a way which, if followed, the world will forever applaud, and God must forever bless.”
Lincoln understood that around the world, freedom’s foes and friends are watching America; that freedom’s future depends on America; that America must always be on the side of freedom; that America should use its blessings to support those willing to fight for freedom. Ukrainians are doing just that. Unlike so many other battlegrounds where Americans have fallen, Ukraine has not asked for American boots on the ground, only for the tools to defend herself. Yet U.S. aid to Ukraine plunged 99 percent between January 2025 and February 2026, according to the Kiel Institute. Although some U.S. weapons continue to trickle into Ukraine under a NATO program that allows European countries to purchase and transfer U.S. munitions, U.S. material support for Ukraine has not rebounded. The party of Lincoln should change that.
President Theodore Roosevelt argued, “There are occasional crimes committed on so vast a scale and of such peculiar horror as to make us doubt whether it is not our manifest duty to endeavor at least to show our disapproval of the deed and our sympathy with those who have suffered by it,” adding that there are times to act “in the interest of humanity at large.” In TR’s day, it was “intolerable conditions in Cuba,” “the massacre of the Jews in Kishinev,” “cruelty and oppression” against Armenians.
In our day, it is North Korea’s vast prison state, Beijing’s forced-labor camps and brutalization of Uyghurs and persecution of Christians, Russia’s filtration camps and mass-rapes and mass-kidnappings and terror bombings. Acting “in the interest of humanity at large” may be too much to ask of the America First crowd. But expressing outrage at these crimes, contempt for the regimes committing them and sympathy for their victims would be a good start. At the very least, the party of TR should draw the line at exchanging “love letters” with Kim Jong Un, fawning over Xi Jinping and praising Vladimir Putin.
President Dwight Eisenhower explained, “We could be the wealthiest and the most mighty nation, and still lose the battle of the world, if we do not help our world neighbors protect their freedom and advance their social and economic progress”; called NATO “the last remaining chance for the survival of Western civilization”; and heaped scorn on those who cling to “a vain hope of appeasing dictators.”
But the party of Eisenhower stood aside while USAID was eviscerated and PEPFAR was frozen, while NATO was browbeaten and undermined and nearly broken, while Putin was placated and rewarded, while Xi was feted, while Kim was celebrated, while Ukraine was humiliated and blamed for Putin’s war, while Denmark was threatened, while Canada’s sovereignty was mocked. The party of Eisenhower needs a massive transfusion of Eisenhower’s clear-headed, clear-eyed defense of the free world—and his disdain for its enemies.
President Ronald Reagan, in an echo of Lincoln, called America the “shining city upon a hill…a tall, proud city built on rocks stronger than oceans, wind-swept, God-blessed, and teeming with people of all kinds living in harmony and peace; a city with free ports that hummed with commerce and creativity. And if there had to be city walls, the walls had doors and the doors were open to anyone with the will and the heart to get here.”
That’s a vision of America most Americans embrace—and most of the world admires: a diverse people strengthened by their diversity and bound by something more than the blood and soil of the Old World; a nation fueled by free markets and free trade; a country confident enough to open its arms and doors to anyone with the courage to find a way here, anyone willing to contribute to the harmony of the whole. The party of Reagan—for its own good and its own future, for America’s good and America’s future—should return to that winsome, hopeful vision of America.
“The United States alone cannot right the world’s wrongs,” President George H.W. Bush conceded. “But we also know that some crises in the world cannot be resolved without American involvement, that American action is often necessary as a catalyst for broader involvement of the community of nations.”
Bush understood that America is not omnipotent and, as such, cannot solve or salve all the problems in this broken world. But he also recognized—and endeavored to help the American people recognize—that America is uniquely equipped to serve as civilization’s first responder and last line of defense, that America cannot lead from behind or lead by intimidation, that America should always be guided by that ancient admonishment, “To whom much is given, much is expected.” The party of Bush should remember that and be guided by that.
American Ideas
Importantly, those men used the bully pulpit to make the case for their ideas and worked hard to build consensus around those ideas. As a result, their ideas became American ideas—not just Republican ideas.
Democratic presidents did likewise.
Borrowing from Lincoln, President Franklin Roosevelt argued that “Freedom of person and security of property anywhere in the world depend upon the security of the rights and obligations of liberty and justice everywhere in the world.” FDR was first president to use the term “free world.” His successors—Republicans and Democrats—followed his lead and employed the phrase routinely to rally the American people, unite our allies and define our enemies.
President Harry Truman challenged America to “help free peoples maintain their free institutions.” In West Berlin and South Korea, Kosovo and Kabul and Kiev, he and most of his successors—Republicans and Democrats—tried to live up to that challenge.
President Bill Clinton believed, “We need to be creating a world that we would like to live in when we’re not the biggest power on the block.” That requires building and strengthening institutions founded on free government, free markets and free trade; promoting international norms of behavior; strengthening alliances that share our values and defend our interests; and supporting fellow members of the free world. Some of his successors—both Republicans and Democrats—pushed toward that goal; some of his successors—both Republicans and Democrats—drifted away from it.
Constitutional Power
Speaking of the free world, the new Congress could start rebuilding what might be called a “free world consensus,” restoring some moral basis to foreign policy, chipping away at horseshoe isolationism, and extending bridges across the aisle by dusting off constitutional powers and prerogatives that have lain dormant far too long.
For example, Congress could wield the power of the purse, the advice-and-consent power, and the power to investigate to: restart and ensure sustained support for Ukraine; halt U.S. troop withdrawals from Europe; restore America’s commitment to deliver Tomahawk land-attack missiles to Germany; guarantee the delivery of promised defensive aid to Taiwan; rationalize, right-size or wind down the Iran war; resurrect USAID to serve U.S. interests and promote U.S. ideals; reestablish stability, predictability and sanity in U.S. trade policy; and shine a disinfecting light on foreign influence.
Congress should also use its constitutional powers to mandate humane treatment of immigrants—not only because it is just, but because immigrants are the lifeblood and wellspring of America, because America’s image on the world stage matters, because that image is being destroyed by a Praetorian guard of masked militiamen rounding up brown people, targeting immigrants, and arresting law-abiding immigrants and U.S. citizens.
Congress is a coequal branch of government. Now is a good time for it to start acting like it.
Good Policy
There’s broad support for these policy adjustments: 64 percent of Americans support sending weapons to Ukraine; nearly 90 percent view Putin’s Russia as an enemy/competitor; a nearly-identical share of Americans view Xi’s China as an enemy/competitor; 62 percent see North Korea as an adversary. Sixty-six percent of Americans want the U.S. to lead on the world stage; 68 percent support maintaining or increasing U.S. commitment to NATO. Almost 70 percent say tariffs hurt the economy; 83 percent believe free-trade agreements advance American foreign policy. Six in ten of us disapprove of the federal government’s handling of immigration.
Add it all up, and the “free world consensus”—shaped by our ideals and in defense of our interests—is not only good policy. It’s good politics.
“If we should pay merely lip service to inspiring ideals, and later do violence to simple justice, we would draw down upon us the bitter wrath of generations yet unborn,” Truman warned. Forty years later, Reagan cited that Truman quote verbatim to make the case that “U.S. foreign policy leadership must always reflect a deep understanding of fundamental American interests, values and principles.” In that same speech, Reagan called Congress a “significant partner in foreign policy-making” and reminded lawmakers that “They have a responsibility to go beyond mere criticism to consensus-building that will produce positive, practical and effective action.”
America—and the world—need the new Congress to heed those words.